Woman with AI earrings sparks Dutch artwork controversy

Girl with AI earrings sparks Dutch art controversy

In the beginning look it kind of feels to be only a fashionable tackle Johannes Vermeer’s masterpiece “Woman with a Pearl Earring”. However glance extra intently and issues get just a little atypical.

Initially, there are two sparkling earrings within the symbol placing within the Mauritshuis museum within the Dutch town of The Hague. And are not the ones freckles on her face if truth be told… a fairly inhuman color of purple?

That is for the reason that paintings—one in all a number of fan recreations changing the 1665 authentic whilst it is on mortgage for an enormous Vermeer display at Amsterdam’s Rijksmuseum—was once made the usage of synthetic intelligence (AI).

Its presence has sparked a fierce debate, with questions over whether or not it belongs within the hallowed halls of the Mauritshuis—and whether or not it must be classed as artwork in any respect.

“It is arguable, so persons are for it or in opposition to it,” Mauritshuis press officer Boris de Munnick instructed AFP.

“The individuals who decided on this, they preferred it, they knew that it was once AI, however we preferred the advent. So we selected it, and we hung it.”


Berlin-based virtual writer Julian van Dieken submitted the picture after the Mauritshuis requested folks to ship of their variations of the well-known portray for an set up known as “My Woman with a Pearl”.

Van Dieken stated he had used the AI instrument Midjourney—which will generate complicated footage at the foundation of a instructed, the usage of hundreds of thousands of pictures from the web—and Photoshop.

The Mauritshuis then selected it as one in all 5 pictures out of three,482 submitted via enthusiasts that may be revealed and bodily hung within the room the place “Woman with a Pearl Earring” is usually housed.

“It is surreal to peer it in a museum,” van Dieken wrote on Instagram.

The budding artists ranged in age from 3 to 94, depicting the “Woman” in various types starting from a puppet to a dinosaur and a work of fruit.

However the resolution to make a choice an AI-generated symbol sparked a backlash.

Dutch artist Iris Compiet stated at the Instagram feed for the Mauritshuis exhibition that it was once a “disgrace and an unbelievable insult”, and dozens of others piled in.

“It is an insult to the legacy of Vermeer and in addition to any running artist. Coming from a museum, it is a actual slap within the face,” Compiet instructed AFP.

She stated AI equipment breach the copyright of alternative artists via the usage of their works as the bottom for artificially generated pictures, in addition to scraping the information of web customers usually.

The picture itself she described as “nearly Frankensteinish”.

Artist Eva Toorenent, of the Eu Guild for Synthetic Intelligence Legislation, criticised what she known as the “unethical generation”.

“With out the paintings of human artists, this program may now not generate works in any respect,” she was once quoted as announcing via the Dutch newspaper De Volkskrant.

‘What’s artwork?’

“It is this sort of tricky query—what’s artwork, and what isn’t artwork?” stated the Mauritshuis’s de Munnick.

However he insisted that the museum, whose assortment boasts 3 Vermeers and just about a dozen Rembrandts, had now not intentionally got down to make an inventive observation on AI.

“Our opinion is, we predict it is a great image, we predict it is a inventive procedure,” he stated. “We aren’t the museum to speak about if AI belongs in an artwork museum.”

He admitted although that “up shut, you notice that the freckles are just a little spooky.”

Guests to the Mauritshuis had been similarly divided, he added.

“More youthful folks generally tend to mention, it is synthetic intelligence, what is new. Aged folks infrequently say we adore the extra conventional art work.”

The Mauritshuis was once having a look ahead to the go back of the actual “Woman” in April, he added. The portray’s popularity has larger lately because of a 1999 novel via US writer Tracy Chevalier and an resulting Hollywood movie.

“Neatly, she is lovely within the (Rijksmuseum) exhibition… However we will be able to be more than happy when she is at house.”

© 2023 AFP

Woman with AI earrings sparks Dutch artwork controversy (2023, March 10)
retrieved 14 March 2023
from https://techxplore.com/information/2023-03-girl-ai-earrings-dutch-art.html

This report is matter to copyright. Aside from any honest dealing for the aim of personal find out about or analysis, no
section is also reproduced with out the written permission. The content material is supplied for info functions most effective.

Supply By way of https://techxplore.com/information/2023-03-girl-ai-earrings-dutch-art.html